It was announced about a month ago but was showcased at E3. What we got to see was a very nice looking MMOFPS with a unique twist.
Unlike your traditional MMO where what you do does not matter the new Trion Worlds MMO, Defiant, will be co-funded by American space network Syfy and will help develop a new television show of the same name. The goal here is that the changes in the game are going to have a direct impact on the scripting of the television show.
It’s a unique concept that gives the potential for huge success. I’m sure Trion is looking at the massive success of Battlestar Galactica Online which has almost 8M players. Battlestar Galactica Online is a game that is released years after the show was cancelled and far out of the prime of the television show. However with Syfy fully supporting the game it has risen to become one of the most popular MMOs in the world.
The risk of this concept lies entirely on Trion Worlds. Trion will be relying on Syfy to keep the television show running and continuing to write content for the television show and the game.
However this relies on two levels of interest. The first is the interest of a gaming market. If they can attract a sizeable audience to the game this will help keep the television show coming and since fans will watch it regardless (since they play the game) then they can continue to write the storyline of the game. A show operates on a season so presumably the game can also have yearly or biyearly updates.
The problem comes in if the television show doesn’t take off. I mean if the game doesn’t take off they can just market it to death and attract some size of a crowd.
But what if the television show doesn’t take off.
It gets cancelled.
Syfy is notorious for cancelling flops and paying for it later. One of my favorite shows when I was young was Farscape. This tracked the story of a mouthy captain who warps to another galaxy. The show got cancelled after two seasons in which because of it’s insane popularity the show makers made a TV movie which ended up being one of Syfy’s highest rates programs (for the time).
Another good example of a show they just gave up on was Caprica. Now this wasn’t the greatest show by any means. It was definitely an empty shell when compared to Battlestar Galactica (which it’s a prequel to) however it wasn’t an awful show. It was a show that was just spreading it’s wings. Unlike Battlestar Galactica where everything is purposely teched down to the simplest regions the city of Caprica is supposed to be a technological marvel which is so high tech the Cylons are supposed to be able to take it over. So the show tried to illustrate just how gleamingly complicated and technological this society is. They indeed showed that the Cylon robots just might have… souls. But then before it went anywhere it got cut off. In it’s place will be another prequel to Battlestar Galactica featuring a young Adama as a young pilot.
Basically if this show doesn’t take off after a season, Syfy will cancel it. This means cutting off Trion’s support for the game and in turn cutting off their part in story writing.
It then falls on Trion, not Syfy to find an appropriate following for this game. Sure having Syfy on your side will attract some people to the game. However this is not a free game like Battlestar Galactica is. Fans of BSG are going to be attracted to that game because it requires no purchasing. This is the same with TV. I wouldn’t want to pay per program. That would be horrible. So I essentially get my TV for free (minus that monthly subscription fee right?). Now they need to try and sell this game which will be running the same time it airs.
The primary argument I make is this, if the show fails, the game fails. If the game fails, the show fails.
In that right each has to be able to succeed on their own or they will fail together.
Codependency suggests that because you are both ‘in it’ you should be able to succeed with more room for failure. The opposite ends up being true since human nature tells us to go for the cheap buck… not the long term investment. Why else do you think that Lost